
Published study
Why it was hard to tell whether perinatal stress programmes worked
The foundation of a credible programme is evidence: was it delivered as intended, and did it work?
- 16 trial reports
- 14 programmes
- The challenge
- Stress and anxiety around pregnancy and birth are exactly what these programmes aim to reduce. But trials produced mixed results, which raised a more basic question: were the programmes being delivered as intended?
- Approach
- I reviewed 16 trial reports covering 14 programmes, looking at how often researchers checked that each programme was delivered as designed.
- Impact
- On average, the trials reported using only 45% of recommended fidelity strategies, from 22% for provider training to 54% for study design. That leaves a serious blind spot: if outcomes are weak, you cannot tell whether the programme failed or was never properly delivered.
